Search Icon
netflix
hulu_plus
amazon_prime
showtime
hbo
& more all in one place. Totally free to use!
Movies
arrow
Get recommendations and notifications when movies & shows come to your streaming services.
On
Shudder
arrow
Netflix
Netflix
Hulu
Hulu
Prime Video
Prime Video
HBO
HBO
Showtime
Showtime
Starz
Starz
Mubi
Mubi
Cinemax
Cinemax
CBS All Access
CBS All Access
Fandor
Fandor
AcornTV
AcornTV
Hallmark Movies Now
Hallmark Movies Now
Shudder
Shudder
Epix
Epix
BritBox
BritBox
FX
FX
Hallmark
Hallmark
Sundance
Sundance
TBS
TBS
TNT
TNT
IFC
IFC
TCM
TCM
arrowarrow
Want to Select more than one service? Add your services to your free Reelgood account to see everything you can watch!

Mystery Movies on Shudder

See the best Mystery movies by using the sorts and filters below. Sort these Mystery movies by Rotten Tomatoes score, IMDB score, popularity, release date, alphabetical order, to find the top recommendations for you. Want to see what you have access to based on your Streaming Services (Netflix, Hulu, Prime Video, HBO etc)? Enter your streaming services and we'll only show things you can watch included with the subscriptions you already have. Clicking play will start auto-playing any movies you click on.

Sort by Defaultcaret
RatingAvailable On
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo Poster
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo200918+7.886%
free
fandor
doc_
shudder
sund
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Halloween Poster
Halloween197818+7.895%
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Rear Window Poster
Rear Window19547+8.5100%
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Summer of 84 Poster
Summer of 842018N/A6.770%
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Oldboy Poster
Oldboy200318+8.480%
free
fandor
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
The Girl Who Played with Fire Poster
The Girl Who Played with Fire200918+7.270%
free
fandor
doc_
shudder
sund
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
A Tale of Two Sisters Poster
A Tale of Two Sisters200318+7.285%
free
shudder
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Revenge Poster
Revenge201718+6.392%
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Sleepy Hollow Poster
Sleepy Hollow199918+7.468%
cbs_all_access
epix
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers Poster
Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers198818+5.927%
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Vertigo Poster
Vertigo19587+8.396%
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
I Know What You Did Last Summer Poster
I Know What You Did Last Summer199718+5.736%
free
netflix
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Jacob's Ladder Poster
Jacob's Ladder199018+7.571%
amazon_prime
epix
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Black Death Poster
Black Death201018+6.470%
free
shudder
warr
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
31 Poster
31201618+5.149%
free
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers Poster
Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers198918+5.213%
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
A Girl Walks Home Alone at Night Poster
A Girl Walks Home Alone at Night2014N/A7.096%
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Sleepaway Camp Poster
Sleepaway Camp198318+6.381%
free
amazon_prime
shout_factory_tv
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
The 'Burbs Poster
The 'Burbs19897+6.953%
amazon_prime
epix
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
The House by the Cemetery Poster
The House by the Cemetery198118+6.238%
epix
full
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
The Awakening Poster
The Awakening201118+6.562%
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Hellraiser III: Hell on Earth Poster
Hellraiser III: Hell on Earth199218+5.541%
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
The Corpse of Anna Fritz Poster
The Corpse of Anna Fritz2015N/A5.967%
free
shudder
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
The Others Poster
The Others200113+7.683%
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Take Shelter Poster
Take Shelter201118+7.492%
free
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Triangle Poster
Triangle200918+6.980%
free
amazon_prime
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Orphan Poster
Orphan200918+7.055%
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Ong Bak: Muay Thai Warrior Poster
Ong Bak: Muay Thai Warrior200318+7.286%
free
hulu_plus
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Tell No One Poster
Tell No One2006N/A7.594%
free
fandor
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
V/H/S Poster
V/H/S201218+5.8N/A
free
hulu_plus
mons
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Tenebre Poster
Tenebre198218+7.272%
cont
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Mother Poster
Mother200918+7.896%
netflix
dox
mons
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
The Void Poster
The Void2016N/A5.876%
netflix
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Grave Encounters Poster
Grave Encounters2011N/A6.164%
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Deep Red Poster
Deep Red197518+7.796%
free
amazon_prime
epix
full
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Hellbound: Hellraiser II Poster
Hellbound: Hellraiser II198818+6.556%
hbo
hulu_plus
cinemax
cont
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
The Changeling Poster
The Changeling198018+7.380%
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
The Collector Poster
The Collector200918+6.429%
free
amazon_prime
showtime
hulu_plus
cont
scre
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Phenomena Poster
Phenomena198518+6.878%
free
amazon_prime
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Don't Hang Up Poster
Don't Hang Up201618+5.625%
free
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Black Christmas Poster
Black Christmas197418+7.271%
free
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Ong Bak 2 Poster
Ong Bak 2200818+6.248%
hulu_plus
shudder
warr
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
The Innkeepers Poster
The Innkeepers201118+5.580%
amazon_prime
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
All Cheerleaders Die Poster
All Cheerleaders Die2013N/A5.153%
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Willow Creek Poster
Willow Creek2013N/A5.187%
amazon_prime
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
The Faculty Poster
The Faculty199818+6.553%
free
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Let Us Prey Poster
Let Us Prey201418+5.782%
amazon_prime
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
A Christmas Horror Story Poster
A Christmas Horror Story2015N/A5.780%
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Prom Night Poster
Prom Night198018+5.445%
free
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon
Wishmaster 3: Beyond the Gates of Hell Poster
Wishmaster 3: Beyond the Gates of Hell200118+3.6N/A
free
shudder
+ Rent or Buy
Want To SeeWant To See Icon
SeenCheck Mark Icon