Mystery
AllAction & AdventureAnimationBiographyComedyCrimeCultDocumentaryDramaFamilyFantasyHistoryHorrorIndependentLGBTQMusicalMysteryRomanceScience-FictionThrillerAdaptationAlienAnimalApocalypseBased on BooksBased On True StoryCarChristmasCollegeComic BookComing of AgeDanceDark ComedyDatingDisasterDoctorDogDrugDystopiaEgyptEscapeFashionFeel-goodFemale DirectorFightingFriendshipFuturisticGangGangsterGhostGolfGreeceGymnasticsHigh SchoolHolidayHuntingJungleKidnappingMagicMartial ArtsMatureMedicalMedievalMilitaryMonsterMusicNew YorkPetPolicePoliticalPrisonPsychologyReligionRevengeRiverRobotRoyaltyScienceSerial KillerSpaceSportsSuperheroSupernaturalSurvivalSuspenseTeacherTechnologyTeenTime TravelToyTwinsVampireVideo GamesWarWorld War IIWrestlingZombie
Movies
Get recommendations and notifications when movies & shows come to your streaming services.
On
Shudder
Want to Select more than one service? Add your services to your free Reelgood account to see everything you can watch!
Mystery Movies on Shudder
See the best Mystery movies by using the sorts and filters below. Sort these Mystery movies by Rotten Tomatoes score, IMDB score, popularity, release date, alphabetical order, to find the top recommendations for you. Want to see what you have access to based on your Streaming Services (Netflix, Hulu, Prime Video, HBO etc)? Enter your streaming services and we'll only show things you can watch included with the subscriptions you already have. Clicking play will start auto-playing any movies you click on.
Sort by Default
| Rating | Available On | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 | The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo | 2009 | 18+ | 7.8 | 86% |   doc_  sund + Rent or Buy | Want To See  Seen  | ||
 | Halloween | 1978 | 18+ | 7.8 | 95% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Rear Window | 1954 | 7+ | 8.5 | 100% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Summer of 84 | 2018 | N/A | 6.7 | 70% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Oldboy | 2003 | 18+ | 8.4 | 80% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | The Girl Who Played with Fire | 2009 | 18+ | 7.2 | 70% | doc_ sund + Rent or Buy | Want To See Seen | ||
 | A Tale of Two Sisters | 2003 | 18+ | 7.2 | 85% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Revenge | 2017 | 18+ | 6.3 | 92% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Sleepy Hollow | 1999 | 18+ | 7.4 | 68% |   | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers | 1988 | 18+ | 5.9 | 27% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Vertigo | 1958 | 7+ | 8.3 | 96% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | I Know What You Did Last Summer | 1997 | 18+ | 5.7 | 36% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Jacob's Ladder | 1990 | 18+ | 7.5 | 71% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Black Death | 2010 | 18+ | 6.4 | 70% | warr + Rent or Buy | Want To See Seen | ||
 | 31 | 2016 | 18+ | 5.1 | 49% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers | 1989 | 18+ | 5.2 | 13% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | A Girl Walks Home Alone at Night | 2014 | N/A | 7.0 | 96% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Sleepaway Camp | 1983 | 18+ | 6.3 | 81% |  | Want To See Seen | ||
 | The 'Burbs | 1989 | 7+ | 6.9 | 53% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | The House by the Cemetery | 1981 | 18+ | 6.2 | 38% | full | Want To See Seen | ||
 | The Awakening | 2011 | 18+ | 6.5 | 62% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Hellraiser III: Hell on Earth | 1992 | 18+ | 5.5 | 41% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | The Corpse of Anna Fritz | 2015 | N/A | 5.9 | 67% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | The Others | 2001 | 13+ | 7.6 | 83% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Take Shelter | 2011 | 18+ | 7.4 | 92% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Triangle | 2009 | 18+ | 6.9 | 80% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Orphan | 2009 | 18+ | 7.0 | 55% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Ong Bak: Muay Thai Warrior | 2003 | 18+ | 7.2 | 86% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Tell No One | 2006 | N/A | 7.5 | 94% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | V/H/S | 2012 | 18+ | 5.8 | N/A | mons | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Tenebre | 1982 | 18+ | 7.2 | 72% | cont | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Mother | 2009 | 18+ | 7.8 | 96% | dox mons | Want To See Seen | ||
 | The Void | 2016 | N/A | 5.8 | 76% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Grave Encounters | 2011 | N/A | 6.1 | 64% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Deep Red | 1975 | 18+ | 7.7 | 96% | full | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Hellbound: Hellraiser II | 1988 | 18+ | 6.5 | 56% |  cont | Want To See Seen | ||
 | The Changeling | 1980 | 18+ | 7.3 | 80% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | The Collector | 2009 | 18+ | 6.4 | 29% | cont scre | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Phenomena | 1985 | 18+ | 6.8 | 78% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Don't Hang Up | 2016 | 18+ | 5.6 | 25% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Black Christmas | 1974 | 18+ | 7.2 | 71% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Ong Bak 2 | 2008 | 18+ | 6.2 | 48% | warr + Rent or Buy | Want To See Seen | ||
 | The Innkeepers | 2011 | 18+ | 5.5 | 80% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | All Cheerleaders Die | 2013 | N/A | 5.1 | 53% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Willow Creek | 2013 | N/A | 5.1 | 87% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | The Faculty | 1998 | 18+ | 6.5 | 53% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Let Us Prey | 2014 | 18+ | 5.7 | 82% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | A Christmas Horror Story | 2015 | N/A | 5.7 | 80% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Prom Night | 1980 | 18+ | 5.4 | 45% | | Want To See Seen | ||
 | Wishmaster 3: Beyond the Gates of Hell | 2001 | 18+ | 3.6 | N/A | | Want To See Seen |